An Elected Mayor for Lodi? What Each Option Would Change at City Hall

An Elected Mayor for Lodi? What Each Option Would Change at City Hall

At a Glance

The Lodi City Council is working on a written rule for how the mayor's title rotates among its five members. Steve Mann's About Town column for November 19 used that moment to ask a bigger question of 13 current, former and incoming council members: should Lodi voters elect the mayor directly? The answers split almost evenly. This report sorts out what each option would mean. The short version is that state law already lets a city like Lodi elect its mayor without changing who runs City Hall, that doing so would force the city to redraw its council districts, and that a "strong mayor" who runs the city is a separate and much larger change used by only five cities in California.

13
Lodi council members, past, present and incoming, asked in About Town
5 to 5
Clear yes versus clear no, with three in between
4 or 6
Council districts Lodi would need with an elected mayor, instead of 5
5
California cities with a strong mayor, out of 482
78%
Elk Grove's 2010 vote to elect its mayor directly

How Lodi Chooses Its Mayor Today

Lodi has used the council-manager form of government since March 1948. The five council members set policy and the budget. They hire a city manager, who runs daily operations and supervises staff. The mayor is one of the five, chosen by the council each year under Lodi Municipal Code 2.04.070. The mayor runs the meetings, signs documents and represents the city at events, and has one vote like everyone else.

The yearly choice has followed an informal rotation, and the council has not always kept to it. In December 2018 the council passed over JoAnne Mounce, who was next in line, and chose Mark Chandler. In January 2026 the council asked staff to put a rotation by district in writing. The proposal that came back on the October 21 agenda works like this: the mayor pro tempore's district moves up to mayor the following year if that member has at least 12 straight months on the council, the next district in numerical order becomes mayor pro tempore, and the council can set the order aside with four of five votes. It would start with the 2027 selection, with District 5 as mayor and District 1 as mayor pro tempore. Mann's column describes approval as still ahead.

A written rotation settles who is next. It does not change what the mayor does. The question Mann put to the former mayors is a different one.


Where Lodi's Current and Former Council Members Stand

Thirteen people who have held or are about to hold a council seat answered. Five want voters to elect the mayor, five want to keep the council's choice, and three gave answers that depend on something else. The grouping below is LodiEye's reading of the positions reported in the column.

Positions on a directly elected mayor, as reported in About Town

Source: Steve Mann, About Town, November 19, 2026 edition | Grouping by LodiEye. Former City Manager Steve Schwabauer also commented and is not counted because he did not hold a council seat.

Position Who Main reason given
Elect the mayor Randy Snider, Alan Nakanishi, Doug Kuehne, JoAnne Mounce, Jack Sieglock With district elections, the mayor would be the one member every voter helps choose. Mounce thinks it may require a city charter.
Open, or let voters decide Lisa Craig-Hensley, Mikey Hothi Craig-Hensley points to Manteca and suggests taking it up at the 2030 redistricting. Hothi would put the question on the ballot, as Elk Grove did.
Depends on the form of government Ramon Yepez Council selection fits a ceremonial mayor. A mayor with executive power should be elected, and voters should decide that change.
Keep the council's choice David Warner, Larry Hansen, Phil Katzakian, John Beckman, Mike Carouba The job is ceremonial, the rotation gives each member a turn, the change costs money, and concentrating power carries risk.

Several of these answers are about different things. Some describe a mayor who is elected citywide and still has one vote. Others describe a mayor who runs the city. Katzakian called district voting and an elected mayor "big city stuff," and the objection about concentrated power applies mostly to the second kind. Sorting the options into four models makes the disagreement easier to follow.


The Four Models Used in California

Model Who picks the mayor Who runs daily operations Legal basis California examples
1. Council-selected mayor The council, by yearly vote or rotation City manager State general law Lodi, Davis, Woodland, Folsom, Galt, Oakley
2. Elected mayor, council-manager city Voters citywide City manager State general law, after a local vote Manteca, Elk Grove, Tracy, Lathrop, Turlock, Vacaville
3. Elected mayor with a larger role, council-manager city Voters citywide City manager City charter Stockton, Sacramento, San Jose
4. Strong mayor Voters citywide The mayor City charter Los Angeles, San Diego, San Francisco, Fresno, Oakland

Model 1: The council selects the mayor

This is Lodi's system and the most common arrangement in the state. Davis, a general law city with five districts, has its council appoint a mayor and vice mayor each year. Woodland has rotated the title since it moved to district elections in 2016. Folsom's council elects a mayor by majority vote each year, and Galt's council picks a mayor who serves two years. Oakley has written a rotation schedule into its municipal code, which is close to what Lodi is now considering.

A written rotation is not permanent. Redlands adopted one in 2023 and repealed it on a 4-1 vote less than two years later. Palm Springs has rotated its mayor since 2019, when it moved to districts under threat of a voting rights lawsuit, and held a series of public meetings in 2026 on whether to go back to an elected mayor.

Model 2: Voters elect the mayor, and the city manager still runs the city

This is the "Manteca model" Craig-Hensley mentioned, and it is the realistic option for Lodi. Manteca is a general law city with a council-manager government. It has elected its mayor citywide since 1980, for a four-year term, and since 2022 its four council members have been elected by district. Elk Grove, also a general law city, has elected its mayor since 2012 for a two-year term, with four district council members. Tracy has elected its mayor since a 1984 ballot measure, also for two years. Lathrop elects its mayor for two years. Turlock elects a mayor for four years alongside four district members. Vacaville uses six districts and a citywide mayor.

In all of these cities the mayor is one vote on the council and the city manager remains in charge of staff. State law gives an elected mayor in a general law city two things a rotating mayor does not have: the power to make appointments to boards and commissions with the council's approval, and eligibility for pay above a council member's. The pay difference can be small. Tracy pays council members $1,029 a month and the mayor $1,129.

Model 3: A charter city gives its elected mayor a larger role

Stockton is the nearby example, and it is often described as having a strong mayor. It does not. Stockton's charter sets up a council-manager government. The mayor is elected citywide, works full time, helps shape the council agenda and, since a 2016 charter change, has a three-person staff. The city manager remains the chief administrative officer, and the mayor's authority goes little further than any other council member's. That arrangement has produced friction, including a dispute between the mayor and city manager over who controls the city's public information staff.

Sacramento and San Jose also elect a citywide mayor while keeping a city manager in charge of operations. Sacramento voters turned down strong-mayor proposals in 2014 and again in 2020, each time with about 57% voting no.

Model 4: A strong mayor runs the city

Here the mayor is the chief executive, with authority over departments and usually a veto. Only five California cities use it: Los Angeles, San Diego, San Francisco, Fresno and Oakland. San Diego voters approved it as a trial in 2004 and made it permanent in 2010. Fresno voters approved it in 1993 and it took effect in 1997. Oakland, which had a hybrid system since 1998, voted this month to move to a full strong-mayor structure, with Measure EE at about 74% in unofficial results. All five are charter cities, and the smallest, Oakland and Fresno, are several times Lodi's size.

An elected mayor is not the same as a strong mayor

Electing the mayor changes who chooses the person with the title. A strong mayor changes who runs the city. Lodi could do the first under existing state law. The second would require Lodi voters to adopt a city charter, because a general law city's structure is set by state statute and a charter is what allows a different form of government. Mayor Yepez drew this same line in his answer.


What State Law Requires

Lodi is a general law city, which means its structure comes from the state Government Code instead of a locally written charter. About three-quarters of California cities are organized this way. That answers the question Mounce raised: a charter is not needed to elect the mayor.

Government Code section 34900 lets a city council ask voters whether they want to elect a mayor and four council members, and whether the mayor's term should be two years or four. Elk Grove's 2010 ballot shows how it works in practice. Voters there faced three linked measures: one on whether to elect the mayor, one for a two-year term and one for a four-year term. The first passed with 78%, the two-year term passed with 64%, and the four-year term failed.

A second statute matters more for Lodi. Section 34871 lists the district arrangements a general law city may use: five, seven or nine districts when the council picks the mayor, and four, six or eight districts when the mayor is elected. Lodi has five. An elected mayor would mean redrawing the city into four districts, which keeps a five-member council, or six districts, which makes a seven-member council. A separate section, 34886, lets a council adopt district elections with an elective mayor by ordinance. How these sections would be sequenced in Lodi is a question for the city attorney.

What would not change

Under an elected mayor in a general law city, the council still sets policy by majority vote, the city manager still hires and supervises staff, and the mayor still cannot veto, direct departments or spend money alone. The concern raised in About Town that the change would add to the cost of the city manager's office does not follow from this model, because the city manager's job stays as it is.


The District Map Is the Hard Part

Lodi moved to district elections in 2018 after the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund wrote in October 2017 that at-large voting diluted the Latino vote in violation of the California Voting Rights Act. The letter said Latinos were 20.6% of the city's voting-age citizens and that it appeared no Latino had served on the council. The council adopted five districts by ordinance in March 2018. The 2020 census counted 66,348 residents, 37.8% of them Hispanic or Latino, which put the target for each of the five districts at about 13,270 people.

Residents per council district under each option

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 Census (66,348 residents) | LodiEye arithmetic: population divided by the number of districts. A 2030 redraw would use 2030 census counts.

Going from five districts to four means each district grows by about 3,300 people and one current district is absorbed into its neighbors. Former City Manager Steve Schwabauer told Mann the city looked informally at four districts and a citywide mayor when the first maps were drawn and found it hard to make the numbers work within state rules on keeping communities together. Any new four-district map would be judged against the same voting rights law that prompted districts in the first place. That is LodiEye's analysis, not a legal finding.

Six districts avoids eliminating a seat. It adds two council members, with the pay, benefits and staff time that come with them, and a seven-member council.

The same tension has surfaced elsewhere. In Palm Springs this year, residents told their council that returning to a citywide elected mayor could undercut the representation gains that came with districts. Palm Springs is a charter city, so the proposal there could keep all five districts and add the mayor as a sixth member. A general law city like Lodi does not have that option.

There is also a cost to the mapping itself. Manteca budgeted between $100,000 and $150,000 for a demographer when it drew four districts. Craig-Hensley's suggestion to take the question up with the 2030 redistricting would fold that work into a redraw the city has to do anyway after the next census.


What the Comparison Cities Show

How voters have answered when asked about the mayor's role

Source: Ballotpedia (Elk Grove); Sacramento Observer and Inside Sacramento (Sacramento); KQED and Associated Press (Oakland, unofficial as of November 13, 2026) | Sacramento figures are approximate: about 57% voted no in each election.

Voters tend to say yes to electing the mayor

Elk Grove's 78% is the clearest nearby result. Hothi's suggestion to ask the voters has a likely outcome if Elk Grove is a guide. Strong-mayor proposals are less predictable: Sacramento said no twice, and Oakland just said yes by a wide margin.

A citywide winner can take office without a majority

Manteca's mayoral election has no runoff. Its mayor won in 2010 with 43% in a race with more than two candidates, and Manteca's Charlie Halford has pointed to a Tracy mayor elected with about 35%.

Term length changes the job

Two-year terms, used in Elk Grove, Tracy and Lathrop, put the mayor back on the ballot almost as soon as the term starts. An Elk Grove council member raised that complaint in 2011, before the first mayoral election was held. Four-year terms, used in Manteca and Turlock, avoid that but give voters a say only once every four years on the one seat they all share.

The change is not always the last word

In 2020, eight years after its first mayoral election, the Elk Grove council discussed whether to ask voters to go back to a rotating mayor. It kept the elected office. Palm Springs is studying a move in the opposite direction.

One mandate, one vote

An elected mayor is the only official chosen by the whole city, and still has one vote of five. Stockton shows that a mayor with a citywide mandate and a full-time office can end up in disputes with the city manager even without executive authority. Hansen's point that the current system helps keep relations civil among council members is about this.


What Would Have to Happen in Lodi

If the council wanted to pursue an elected mayor, the general outline under state law would be:

A council decision to put it on the ballot. The questions would cover whether to elect the mayor and the length of the term.

A choice between four and six districts. This is a policy decision with voting rights consequences and would involve public hearings and a demographer.

A new district map. Sitting members' terms and district lines would have to be reconciled, as Turlock and Manteca did during their transitions.

A first mayoral election. Lodi's municipal elections are held in November of even-numbered years.

A strong mayor would be a different process: drafting a city charter, a public vote to adopt it, and decisions about veto power, budget authority and who hires and fires the city manager and department heads.

The rotation rule now before the council and the elected-mayor question are not in conflict. The first is a procedural change the council can make on its own. The second belongs to the voters, and the earliest practical window, if the city ties it to redistricting, is after the 2030 census.


About This Report

LodiEye is the original civic-reporting and analysis arm of Lodi411.com, a citizen-run civic data and transparency platform serving Lodi, California and San Joaquin County. LodiEye gathers information of public interest, applies editorial judgment to public records, meetings, and data, and publishes original explanatory reporting for its readers — the work of a newsroom, and a representative of the news media as that term is defined under federal law. Our reporting emphasizes primary sources, public data, and full source transparency so readers can check every claim. LodiEye complements, and does not replace, the other outlets covering this region; for additional reporting on Lodi, San Joaquin County, and the broader region, we also encourage readers to consult the Lodi News-Sentinel, Stocktonia, The Sacramento Bee, CalMatters, and other established news organizations. Our full editorial standards and news-media-status statement is published at lodi411.com/editorial-standards.

This LodiEye policy analysis was produced using artificial intelligence tools under the direction and review of the founder. Lodi411 uses multiple AI platforms in its research and publication workflow, including Anthropic's Claude and Perplexity AI. These tools were used in the following capacities:

Source Discovery: AI was used to locate primary sources, including the California Government Code sections on elective mayors and council districts, city municipal codes and charters, county election records, the 2017 MALDEF letter to the City of Lodi, and local news coverage of each city compared.

Credibility Validation: AI cross-referenced claims across independent sources, giving priority to statutes, city websites and official election results. Vote totals, term lengths and district counts were checked against those sources, and figures that could not be confirmed exactly are labeled approximate.

Analysis and Synthesis: AI assisted in sorting the positions reported in About Town into groups, organizing the options into four models, and calculating residents per district from 2020 census data.

Presentation: Claude assisted in drafting, structuring and formatting the report, including the comparison tables. Kendo UI charts were specified and built to show the reported positions, the district arithmetic and the ballot measure results.

Final Review: AI reviewed the completed draft for factual consistency, source attribution and balanced presentation. Throughout the process, the editor sets the report's goals, scope, and tone; creates and shapes draft content; reviews and edits the report; and integrates independent fact checks.

Lodi411/LodiEye believes that transparency about how our research is produced — including our use of AI under human direction — strengthens trust with readers and the broader information ecosystem. Readers who spot an error are encouraged to write editor@lodi411.com so we can correct it.

Sources

Previous
Previous

White Slough Data Center: A Second Look Needs Better Numbers

Next
Next

The November 13 Nationwide Ground Stop: What Failed, Who Was Affected, and What Would Prevent Another